Thanks for printing this recipe. Visit AmericasTestKitchenFeed.com for fantastic recipes, cooking tips, gear reviews, and plenty more.
About the Author: John "Doc" Willoughby
John Willoughby was the original executive editor of Cook’s Illustrated when the magazine was founded in 1993. In 2001, he moved to New York to take the job of executive editor at Gourmet magazine, a position that he held until the fall of 2009. In February of 2010, he returned to America’s Test Kitchen to assume the job of executive editor for magazines. John is also the coauthor, with chef Chris Schlesinger, of nine cookbooks, including the award-winning The Thrill of the Grill and How to Cook Meat. He has taught graduate-level courses in food writing at both Boston University and the Radcliffe Seminars at Harvard College, as well as at the Culinary Institute of America at Greystone.
it would be very helpful if a transcript was posted with these videos so i didn’t have to watch the whole thing to get the message
Josho
August 26, 2011 at 11:23 am
Another quick method — that doesn’t use up a plastic bag — is to put the stick of butter on an aluminum pan or pot (actual silver is best and has the fastest heat transfer rate). It’s not as fast as whacking it soft as in the video — something we did at pastry boot camp at the CIA — but in fifteen minutes, it will be nicely softened especially if you turn it from time to time. If you’re prepping your mise en place, and you put the button the pan first, generally by the time you’re ready to bake, the butter will be nicely softened.
timkvfp
August 26, 2011 at 3:08 pm
“…so i didn’t have to watch the whole thing to get the message”
Really? When I saw this I was expecting a 5 minute video, it’s 56 seconds and they cared enough to make it. Relax, take less than a minute and enjoy watching him show that stick of butter how they do things downtown!
robinkirby2
September 14, 2011 at 9:10 am
What is the difference between this and putting the stick of butter in the bowl of an electric mixer and beating the butter before adding sugar when making cookies?
Hi Robin, Sometimes the butter can be too hard (cold, from the fridge) to beat the butter effectively in the mixer bowl, in which you might want to use these softening techniques.
sznv062
June 22, 2012 at 4:42 pm
I always forget to take out the butter So….I get one of those snack size plastic baggies (those things are so great!), put the butter into it and dip it into a hot cup of water. Softens it up really fast. I used to zap it for a second in the microwave, but what I was getting was clarified butter….that won’t do. This little baggie way works everytime
Organized around the seasons with menus that serve eight, plus a special holiday and for-a-crowd chapter, The America's Test Kitchen Menu Cookbook takes all the guesswork out of putting together flavorful and practical menus. Packed with tips that will help you shop and budget your time, this book is a must-have for anyone who likes to entertain.
it would be very helpful if a transcript was posted with these videos so i didn’t have to watch the whole thing to get the message
Another quick method — that doesn’t use up a plastic bag — is to put the stick of butter on an aluminum pan or pot (actual silver is best and has the fastest heat transfer rate). It’s not as fast as whacking it soft as in the video — something we did at pastry boot camp at the CIA — but in fifteen minutes, it will be nicely softened especially if you turn it from time to time. If you’re prepping your mise en place, and you put the button the pan first, generally by the time you’re ready to bake, the butter will be nicely softened.
“…so i didn’t have to watch the whole thing to get the message”
Really? When I saw this I was expecting a 5 minute video, it’s 56 seconds and they cared enough to make it. Relax, take less than a minute and enjoy watching him show that stick of butter how they do things downtown!
What is the difference between this and putting the stick of butter in the bowl of an electric mixer and beating the butter before adding sugar when making cookies?
Hi Robin, Sometimes the butter can be too hard (cold, from the fridge) to beat the butter effectively in the mixer bowl, in which you might want to use these softening techniques.
I always forget to take out the butter
So….I get one of those snack size plastic baggies (those things are so great!), put the butter into it and dip it into a hot cup of water. Softens it up really fast. I used to zap it for a second in the microwave, but what I was getting was clarified butter….that won’t do. This little baggie way works everytime