Recipe File

Homemade Salted Caramels

Chew on this: It’s never been easier to make this irresistibly sweet and salty confection.

    Step #10

    Login to View This Recipe

    This recipe is free, but you must first  to see it. As always, all content and recipes on America's Test Kitchen Feed are free to view. Don't have an account? Sign up now to view free recipes, leave comments and more!

    16 Comments

    • Jen

      Just made this! I didn’t have a square dish but I have a feeling they will still turn out great. :)

    • Scott

      I CANNOT get these to harden enough to cut and wrap. The caramel that gets left behind in my saucepan does, though. It also sticks to the wax paper no matter how well I grease it or don’t. I’ve tried three times! Please help!

    • jacnsac916

      I always looking for something new to make. I love carmel but i’m a little nervous to make then :-/ Haven’t had the greatest luck using a candy thermometer. If it turns out – i will make it annually and add to my annual Christmas treats.So far i have my tried and true – Jam Thumbprints, Cranberry orange bread and hoping for the best with these carmels! I just need one more treat…must be something chocolate!! :)

    • Christine Liu
      Christine Liu

      Hi jacnsac916, you sound like your kitchen will be extra sweet this season! If you’re looking for something chocolate, have you seen the brigadeiros? So cute and very easy: http://www.americastestkitchenfeed.com/do-it-yourself/2011/07/how-to-make-brigadeiros/

    • harvest

      When I click on the recipe link it takes me to a log in page even though I am logged in. Who do I need to bug to fix that so I can see the recipe?

    • Christine Liu
      Christine Liu

      Hi harvest, that would be me! Will email you now to resolve your issue.

    • Jen

      The recipe turned out great by the way. I’m making them again again today.

    • Keirstin

      These are amazing! Making them for the 3rd time this season today.

    • Emily

      @Scott It sounds like you’re taking off the caramel before it hits 248 degrees, but you can definitely put it back on the stove and re-boil it… just make sure you have a good thermometer handy!

    • tmarrinson

      My wife gave me a book on cooking chemistry and I found that you don’t have to wash the sides of the pan during the sugar melt as long as you are melting raw sugar AND corn syrup together. I also add 5 drops of lemon juice before I start melting the sugar which also prevents the sugar from crystalizing. I found it MUCH easier to not have to worry about washing the side of the pan and just focus on swirling the pan over the heat. Also, I purchased one of the Thermapens and it is awesome. Well worth the price, and gives you quick and accurate readings. And whoever suggested the non-stick aluminum foil was spot on! That works really well too. I’ve made multiple batches of these caramels and they are amazing!

    • r.m.l-1022

      Help! What am I doing wrong? Mine are turning out SO greasy and dripping with butter! My husband loves salted caramels and I’d like to perfect this recipe in time for Valentine’s Day. Any help is much appreciated!

    • Karey

      HELP! Mine didn’t set AND tasted burnt… Here’s the thing: I used a non-stick pot, and I waited about 30 seconds before mixing in the cream and the temperature had risen to 400+. Consequently, when I added the cream, the temperature was still above 300, and I wasn’t sure about the second cooking. I let it cool a little and heated it back up to 248 as directed. Any thoughts on any of these things.

      My theory is that the non-stick pot allowed the “burnt edges”, that would normally be stuck on the sides, to immediately reabsorb creating a slightly burnt taste. As to why it wouldn’t set, I have no idea…

    • Amy

      Love this recipe- I used a Thermapen and they turned out perfectly the first time around, which I think is what saved me.

    • photobug

      I’m having the same problem as jacnsac916 but when trying to get to the recipe for Homemade Chocolate-Hazelnut Spread. It tells me to log in every time, but will never show me that recipe.

    • Christine Liu
      Christine Liu

      Hi photobug, if you’re signed in, you should be able to access the recipe here: http://www.americastestkitchenfeed.com/recipes/homemade-chocolate-hazelnut-spread/

    • kprussing

      Has anyone else added those 5 drops of lemon. Just want to make
      sure I don’t mess up the original ATK recipe.

    What did you think of this recipe?

    In order to post comments, you must login. Need an account? Register Now, it's free!

    You must be to post a comment.

    Most Popular Stories

    Coming Up Next

    We'll show you the five cheesiest kitchen shortcuts you'll ever need.